Corporate America Loves Queers!?
In my chosen hometown of Seattle, last year’s Pride was different. It was downtown instead of in the hip queer-ish Capital Hill neighborhood. It was bigger, it was longer and it was decidedly more corporate. I know because I was marching toward the end of it in full high-femme burlesque get-up in a rainbow line of other queer burlesque vixens: I was Ms. Violet. We did the bump and grind through mountains of ads, fliers, and free junk.
“The gay and lesbian liberation movement has turned into a gay and lesbian marketing movement” and complains that “a political movement is not what is being sold.” said the National Gay and Lesbian Task Force’s Urvashi Vaid.
Why does Pride have corporate sponsors in the first place? One city’s website answers:
“Portland Pride cannot be funded entirely with donations and booth fees. Rather than charge admission or raise booth fees, Pride Northwest has several corporate sponsors. Some of them are national, but most are local. Some sponsors give us money, and others donate goods and services we need.”
I admit that’s hard to argue with. We do want a free and comfortable Pride with entertainment and local booths. (Setting up booths and floats and events takes the hard work of laborers and tech people.) And we also want it flamboyant. I mean, we’re Queers and we need to show how fabulous we are. We get one weekend a year to be a little less afraid to kiss our lovers on the street because there are more of us banded together in one spot. It’s the time to live it up big-time.
There is a history of how Pride got to be so corporate in every big city. It has to do with something else that’s been going on simultaneously: As we know, Corporate America is becoming increasingly more gay friendly in terms of hiring practices and personnel. The Human Rights Campaign web site’s National Corporate Sponsors page has this introduction:
“The support from corporate America to the gay, lesbian, bisexual and transgender community is directly tied to HRC’s overall success. Please show your loyalty and support by directing your friends/family to our National Corporate Sponsors, listed below.“
Now, I love the HRC, but a corporation’s sponsorship of Gay Pride does not make me feel like it’s my duty to support them. In fact, these corporations are only the new generation of the same homophobic and patriarchal structures that marginalize queers and other oppressed groups (big business, monopoly, cut-throat capitalism, excess, greed). I don’t owe Corporate America, it owes me. I might support a corporation if it also gives money to gay rights causes and if I approve of all of thier business practices.
So if I have no problem with Corporate America owing me a parade and I don’t shop corporate, so their ads won’t effect me, I guess that’s not the reason I don’t want them paying for my big fabulous parade. I think it’s really the excess paper ad waste and free junk made overseas in sweatshops that really turns me off. It gets cleaned up immediately but it winds up in a landfill instead of being recycled. The only thing I approve of is free condoms.
But while I was marching last year and taking advantage of corporate sponsorship, most of my younger friends were not. They were having their own anti-corporate separate parade in the old neighborhood, lots of independent performance artists scheming for a better world.
I definitely felt torn as I realized that the corporate sponsors could be putting their money toward the legal battle for human rights and gay marriage. Instead, they had a captive audience for thier ad campaigns in exchange for paying for the loads of Mardi Gras beads that ended up in our waste baskets.
This year I’ve decided to perform my naughty Naked Folksinger act with other performers at the pre-show at our local lesbian bar. And then I’m committing some time to a local rights organization. I’m not marching anymore. I got terrible blisters anyway.
For more great articles and views on corporate sponsorship of Pride, visit Nina’s wonderful article from last year.
as a transplant in my now adopted “home” of san francisco, i get to see the full-on roar of commercial queer-washing every pride… i mean one look at the several hundred page official “pride guide” (a tome that could both stun an ox and give editors at vogue cold sweats for product placement and advertising dollars) reveals page after page of corporate “sponsorship”…
but this is nothing new… as a young(er) queer in portland maine, it was clear that corporate america was eager to draw in a new market segment… bling tossed from floats along with coupons… the coors float… the airline float… etc, etc…
has this commodity buy-in brought us any appreciable uptick in acceptance… i’d say it can be argued persuasively in either direction… but it has certainly solidified our consumer queer culture…
In the seven years I’ve been out, I’ve only been to a Pride festival once, and that didn’t include a parade. Personally, as a gay man, I find most Pride parades insulting and counter-productive, so I’d be happy to see a bit more of a corporate attitude for them. I’ve always felt that Pride is the one time of year the GLBT community has to expose the rest of the world to who we really are, and it’s always massively screwed up. We want to show the rest of the world that we’re just like they are and should be treated the same, so we have people in chains and assless chaps ride down the street on giant dildoes? What we *really* should do is show up as who we are every day; doctors, lawyers, police officers, mail carriers, Walmart greeters, Maytag repairpersons, and every other just-like-you job we perform, to show the non-GLBT community that we really *are* like them and there really *isn’t* any reason to be afraid of us (and by extension, oppress us). Perhaps if there was a bit more corporate attitude in Pride, we wouldn’t need to fund so many causes to win us equal rights.
i’m not one to argue for more assless chap floats, but neither am i for the assimilationist position that we should have nothing but corporate lawyers and gap ad clones representing the plurality of queer expression…
and might i remind you it was not the lawyers and mail carriers who said “no!” and fought back at stonewall… it was the drag queens and micellaneous “freaks”…
like it or not, diversity means a diversity of expression… if middle america is “shocked,” they should turn their critical eyes upon themselves… i find violent intolerance and religious fueled hate more shocking than a pride parade…
The point remains that (a) non-GLBT people make up at least 90% of the world, and barring the improbable, will continue to be in control of it, (b) we in the GLBT community have to live in a world controlled by non-GLBT people, (c) as long as those non-GLBT people think we’re all freaks, they’re not going to be motivated to care. If we ever want to obtain equal rights, we have to demonstrate that there is no reason to fear a queer. We’re the ones who suffer when we take one of the few chances we have each year to be seen in masse and make it about being freaks. You do realize that it doesn’t hurt straight people at all to oppress us, and that we have to provide an impetus to change that behavior if we ever want it to happen, right?
You’re quite right that it was the freaks fighting back at Stonewall; it was the Black Panthers fighting back during the Civil Rights Movement, but they weren’t the ones who achieved equal rights for people of color. It was Dr. King and his movement, showing that people of color were no different than white people, who won the victory, and it will be the doctors-lawyers-mailmen next door who prove that GLBT persons are just like straight people who win the victory for us. The only question is how long we put off our own emancipation by insisting on portraying ourselves as freaks.
fear us?
we suffer from pride?
i suppose that seperate but equal, don’t ask don’t tell, and the myriad other ways that queers are supposed to eek out our “acceptance” in a straight world fits into your uncle tom view as well?
there is more queer diversity on earth, bob, than is apparently dreamt of in your philosophy… and when you’ld like a tour of the acceptance and equality that have resulted from dr. king’s sacrifice, come tour my hometown of oakland california for a wake-up…
Thank you, Bob, my thoughts exactly!
wow, sf pride was great (though still a giant commercial for coors, bud, southwest air, and others)
and how telling that the vocal antipride voices on this post are anonymous…