WWYD: Sponsoring Friends in Charity Events
‘œA society that has more justice is a society that needs less charity.’ ‘“ Ralph Nader
I’ve sponsored several friends over the years to pedal in the AIDS Ride or walk for Breast Cancer. A few more than once. They’ve all been gracious in the way they have asked for sponsorship and then thankful upon receiving my donation. I’ve always been happy to give and I’ve typically never been asked more than once a year.
When I was reading the Do The Right Thing column in Money magazine, Jeanne Fleming and Leonard Schwarz offered their view about a friend asking repeatedly if you’ll sponsor them in their charity walk, ride or run.
Here’s the question from one of their readers: ‘œWhen I told my new neighbor I was participating in a triathlon to raise money for a charity, he volunteered to send in a check for $50. I was very appreciative at the time. But since then, he’s asked me to support him in three different runs for worthy causes. I’ve said yes each time, but this is starting to get expensive. At what point can I say no, and what should I tell him?’
Their answer: ‘œHere’s what you do: The next time your neighbor asks you for money, tell him that you wish him well, but unfortunately you can’t help out this time. And keep telling him that until he gives up.’
Then they go on to suggest that as a general rule we shouldn’t be soliciting others for donations. Bottom line: don’t ask!
But that seems a bit harsh’¦ doesn’t it? Or not? I’ve worked remotely from home for almost ten years, but when I did work in an office, I remember the constant stream of requests from co-workers and their children. Girl Scout cookies, gift wrap, you name it. People were always peddling something for a cause.
Fleming and Schwarz continue with their advice, ‘œAmericans are by and large an unusually charitable people. But most of us prefer to devote the lion’s share of our charitable giving budget to the causes that matter to us, not the ones that interest our neighbors. So when you ask someone to support you in an event like the triathlon or to buy a box of candy to help fund your child’s class trip, you’re asking them to put their friendship with you ahead of their own favorite charities. That’s asking for a substantial favor – a favor that shouldn’t be sought lightly or, as your neighbor has, repeatedly.’
In this week’s What Would You Do post, we pose a few questions: Is the request to buy a box of candy for five bucks different than the $200 wanted for the AIDS Ride? And if you don’t want to give, then how do you say no? Do you feel comfortable asking family members but not friends or co-workers? Or is the entire concept of ‘œsponsorship’ just plain weird and this type of charitable giving needs a remodel? And what about those repeat offenders’¦ I’m mean really, how many times is that lesbian going to run a marathon? And if more than once or twice, shouldn’t she pony up the few grand that’s required to participate. After all, it’s her cause and she’s the one running.
As usual, we’d love to hear your thoughts in the comments section below.
I thought I was the only one that hated excessive sponsoring.
At work they make a big deal of the amount of money raised for charity, and I just remember that its the staff not the company that raised the money out of our own pockets.
Of course, I could just be bitter because none of my favourite charities are the favourites of other people.
Great post!
When I decline, my explanation is, “I only support animal welfare charities.” This is true, and I don’t care who it offends. I think we are a society that cares too much about offending others, even at our own emotional and financial expense. At big corporations, it is easy to lose $40/month(on group gifts alone) to celebrate birthdays. Add to that everything else and you’re practically working for free.
I find any canvassing for money in a work environment extremely inappropriate and tacky–esp for dumb crap like throwing baby showers, personal gifts, sales contests, etc,. Personal interests should not be mixed in with work.
I have a general budget for charity. So I figure out whether or not it’s in the budget. Maybe if it’s something I really really want to support, then I’ll find a way. Or I’ll say “I’m sorry, I can’t afford it right now.” At my age, people believe that.
When I was in college such requests came up a lot. Our college was big on encouraging social consciousness, so there were fundraisers, walks, sales, whatnot. I didn’t like feeling guilty about not giving most of the time, but I could honestly say that I didn’t have the money.
I’ve never done a charity event and asked for money. Normally I’ve sponsored myself–I give and I walk because I believe in it. Well, maybe I did once when I was a kid. But I hate asking, so I’d only ask people who I knew wanted to support it.
I have the same misgivings as plonkee.
My charities never end up being the ones that others will “give back” when its “my turn.” Years ago when I did tons of work for the GLBT youth in Syracuse, I was basically making it happen with 3 or 4 other people and some sponsored space. We had referral resources, a phone line, events, weekly peer support, etc etc.
No one ever seemed to have time or money to help– but they were than happy to have us step up to the plate as a face for our community when needed.
And then there’s the whole work environment– where the popular chick is into Bikers for Babies– so everyone should contribute. I really try to not ask of my peers- never bringing in flyers for the bajillion items the kids are expected to sell for school clubs or field trips. I guess I just prefer to lay low andnot go with my hand out for my charities and make sure I don’t let myself getting guilted into others “charitable endeavors.”
Those are all great comments… and I especially like the idea about sponsoring ourself. Makes sense: if we want to walk, ride, run, then we should just pay the sponsorship minimum and be done with it!
Thanks for the thoughts on this topic!
I get hit with this a lot both on the “can you give?” side and also when I ask for donations on the mostly annual event where I do a bike race for charity.
When I ask for donations I don’t really take it personally if people decline or ignore my request. I know everyone only has so much money to go around and if they feel so moved to support this charity at this time (for my event), great. If not, that’s ok too.
I get asked for donations a lot too. Some of my close friends and biking buddies I support each year for their ride. I dont’ mind doing it one bit. They also don’t ask me 6 times a year for something either, though, and it is a charity that I have at least some interest in. My donations can range from $20-$100 depending on my budget, the person, the charity, timing, etc. I do not feel bad declining to donate for others. After all, I can’t sponsor 10 riders in the MS ride just because everyone I know is doing it, right?
At work I have always been pretty selective on where I put money. Years ago when I was first in an office I felt obligated to donate to everything – so and so’s wedding, first baby, girl scout cookies, and on and on. Then I realized, I don’t even know half these people. And, how many people are going to take up a collection when me and my partner make a lasting commitment? (of course I was kinda wrong here as the manager DID give us a card and nice gift certificate which blew me away)
So, this is a GREAT question of the ages, only wish I would’ve written this post myself 😉 And as I see it – as with all things, I get to choose where I put my money. Sometimes I say yes, and other times I say no. It isn’t personal…. (unfortunately not everyone ‘gets’ that which is what makes all this so difficult in the first darn place!).
For “how do you say no” you’re honest. If it’s the charity, say that. If it’s that your cashflow doesn’t allow it at the moment, say that. If it’s that you’ve sponsored a bunch of other people recently, say that.
As someone who has done some sponsored runs (although admittedly more for the exercise than the charity), it doesn’t bother me in the slightest if people don’t sponsor me as long as they’re honest. From my point of view as the asker, don’t ask don’t get. It’s the people who say “um, yeah, no problem” and then avoid me for the next week, or who donate and then sulk that bother me.
And I’ve sponsored friends when I wouldn’t sponsor coworkers just to be supportive and enthusiastic. That’s as valid a reason as liking the charity.
Seems like this falls in the category of learning how to say “no”, politely. There is also the concept of providing support in proportion to the relationship to the person. For instance, in the case of Girl Scout cookies…unless the child approaches me directly, I don’t buy ’em. Having parents sell them for their kids seems patently ridiculous to me. As for other sponsorship…I may support someone but for a token amount…or I may tell them to expect a request from me for my favorite charity in the future.
Frankly work solititation can be a big problem. Since I’m in manangement, I really don’t feel that it is appropriate for me to directly solicit people for support for my causes…I may post a flyer in my office with a sign-up sheet, but that’s the extent, I don’t want to create any pressure for support.
Outside work, anything is fair game, however I do expect quid pro quo; ye that solicit should expect to be solicited!
But back to my original point: learning to say “I’m sorry, but I can’t help you with that right now” isn’t that difficult to say…and can actually be quite liberating in some situations!
So, what about when you just get a mass email? Or website-generated email? Am I still obligated to say “no” directly? Or can I just ignore it?
And my biggest problem is that a lot of these charities have very high overhead. Others, I can’t find any financial information on their website, charity navigator, etc. When I give, I want to know that my money is going to be used wisely.
I used to be a teacher (now SAHM), and when a class did a fundraiser, there were a few kids who would ask every teacher in the school to support them. Fortunately, I had a practicum teacher who just told the kids that she would only buy/sponsor them if they came to her house. I thought that was great (especially because I live on a farm). That kept the sponsorship requests in her social circle, not her work circle. I had an office job where every time something happened (marriage, baby, staff leaving), a card would get circulated with an envelope. You signed the card and then you could contribute a couple bucks or whatever to the envelope for a gift. It was fairly low pressure. The other two ladies in my office would always just say leave the envelope and we would pass it on to the next person. That way, they could sign in private and decide whether or not to contribute without anyone looking on. On the other hand, the head of our department would come around WITH HIS CHILD selling cookies or chocolates or whatever, merrily saying OH, don’t feel pressured to buy anything, as he stood there beaming at his precious child. I have no problem with someone sticking up their information or catalog in the break room so people can see it and choose, and maybe making an announcement that it was available, but I really hated direct solicitation (especially as I was on the bottom of the totem pole, so to speak).
Great article. When my son started daycare, at 8 weeks old, he was sent home with a candy fundraiser within the first month, so they could raise money for the daycare’s field trips. This really felt wrong to me – first of all, a 2 month old obviously isn’t able to sell on their own, leaving all the responsibility to the parents, and second, a 2 month old isn’t going to be going on any field trips – so the benefit of selling would be for the older children. I chose not to participate. Now, my son is almost 3 yrs, and at a different daycare, but still gets sent home with fundraisers, about quarterly. I still don’t feel right asking friends/family to buy overpriced crap, but at the same time, I do want to support the daycare esp. now that he is older and participating in the field trips, arts&crafts, etc. So I usually just write a check to the school, for them to put towards whatever they’re doing the fundraiser for. That way, I support the school, without buying unnecessary stuff and without slighting friends and family by asking them to buy this stuff.
I do not get how charities require a certain amount to participate. Charity has changed since I was a kid. Even now even the Salvation Army will only take certain items.
I love the candy bars but they only get like 50% of the proceeds. I would rather just give directly to the charity.
I usually tell people I don’t want to donate to that I only donate to certain charities (which is true). I don’t think it’s offensive; it just means you & your friends want to help others but have different ways of doing so.
What really bugs me is when people ask for money for their own company / college parties though. I mean, it doesn’t even really help anyone in need.
hello there,
am dennis from uganda, me and some other two friends are starting up a non profit organisation to help the disadvantaged children in our neighbourhood to obtain education, food, clothes and shelter. For whoever has something to give these needy children can contact us at childtomorrowfoundation@yahoo.com, soon a website will be up. Thanks