Health Care: Socialized Medicine
Being a Canadian in America I have been asked several times about what I think of President Obama’s health care reform since it will in a way model Canada’s socialized medicine. First I’d like to say that I like President Obama. I believe he is a breath of fresh air for America. Unfortunately, he has inherited a mess of a country and he has big challenges ahead of him to try to turn this country around.
For me, I love being Canadian and I love Canada’s health care program. I would never give up my Canadian citizenship or the privileges that come with being Canadian.
As a child growing up in the province of Ontario whenever I’d get ear infections or sprain my ankle from sports or whatever accident I got into health-wise my mother or father would drive me to the health clinic that was close to our house. When there I’d see a doctor and he/she would help me and then my family would go home and my parents would NOT get a hefty bill in the mail. Growing into a teen I’d go see my regular family physician for a physical check up and I’d get test done (e.g., blood work, pap smear, x-rays, etc.) and I would NOT get a hefty bill in the mail. Similarly, when my older sister had two babies in the hospital she NEVER got hit with a big medical bill as families do in America for having a baby in the hospital. In Canada, people don’t go into debt or claim bankruptcy because of enormous health bills.
My memory recalls that the hospitals in Ontario were always clean and used state of the art equipment, the doctors were professional and the nurses were courteous. I always had really good experiences using my Ontario Health Card. I am from the province of Ontario and each province has its own health care system albeit they are all socialized. For me, living in the U.S. throughout the year, specifically in California, I don’t purchase any extended health care coverage from let’s say Blue Cross because frankly it’s cheaper for me to buy an airplane ticket back to Canada. I could fly two hours to British Columbia, a western province that would honor my eastern Ontario health card, or I could fly six hours to Toronto, Ontario. I suppose my flight would depend on the severity of my illness . . . but I don’t get sick.
Personally, I think that one of the reasons I am so healthy is that I make healthy lifestyle decisions. I prevent bad health from happening to me by being proactive. I don’t smoke. I don’t use drugs. I eat properly. I exercise. I clear my emotions. I monitor my thought patterns. I put my health first. I create good health for myself and since I do that I don’t need to abuse the health care system I contribute to financially. I have no problem paying into the health care system when I pay my taxes because I am grateful that my taxes will help other people who need medicine. I care about other people and I believe all people should have access to great health care despite their financial bracket. A great country depends on healthy citizens, bottom line.
Walking the beach here in California at Big Corona I have spoken to several locals about President Obama’s health care reform. Some of the men that I have spoken with are Republican and are wealthy. Their thinking is this: ‘œWhy should I have to pay for someone else’s health care? I take care of my family’s health and that’s enough. I work hard for my money and I don’t want our President to tell me how to spend my money.’
By contrast, the Democratic men that I have spoken with have said: ‘œI don’t really understand what socialized health care is and I don’t think anybody in this country really does because we haven’t experienced it. I have seen how corporations put fear into people with their commercials against socialized health care, making socialized health care out to be a monster. As a country, we need to ensure the health and survival of our people and I have no problem contributing to that. The Republicans who are against socialized medicine and who want to penny pinch forget that they are where they are because of this great country. These men and women need to stop being selfish and start contributing to the betterment of our country.’
If I were American I think I would be Democratic. And so like the Democratic men I have spoken with I believe people in America need to open their arms to positive and smart change that is in the BEST interest of ALL people not just in the interest of a few select people with mega bucks.
Well I will have to say go Canada! I have studied Canada’s healthcare system and it is far better at providing care than our own (but to be fair Canada has a much smaller population to cover than does the US). Heck even Cubans get free healthcare. We spend more money and get the worst results of any industrialized nation.
As a healthcare provider in the US system I will say it is badly broken. The issue I struggle with daily is listening to folks who think socialized or government medicine is going to take away their “choices”. I hate to tell them that they have little choice now. Medicare and Medicaid do not allow much choice and what exactly they will pay for is NOT determined by the patient. Private insurance is exactly the same way. But I bite my tongue as it is not my place to say differently, just to treat the person in front of me. . .
Great points, Lana – no one should go into debt over their health. Health care is a basic human right.
Thanks for sharing Lana! I’ve been fighting the health care reform wars on facebook and it’s great to see someone from Canada refuting the rumors. No system is perfect, of course I know that, but moving more towards a universal system is inevitable and, regardless of the fear mongering, if done right, should not only benefit all of us health-wise, but also financially, whether that’s as an individual, a couple, a business, or, our society in general.
Hi Lana – I grew up in Hamilton, Ontario Canada and I now live in Pittsburgh. I have American citizenship and I am fortunate to have very good health insurance. My partner and I both work for multi-national Fortune 100 companies that recognize domestic partnerships – our total health insurance premium per month combined is $85!!! I do recognize that we are fortunate.
I asked my mother, who raised six children in Canada under their socialized medicine, if the system worked for her – and her answer was a resounding yes. We never had to wait for any appointments or treatment and the hospitals were top-notch (we used MacMaster University Hospital mostly.) I’ve asked my sisters who remain in Canada and have several children what they thought about their care – one is well-off and owns her own business and the other is just getting by. Both have health issues – and neither have any real complaints (any more than anyone else would have about their doctor, waiting room times, etc.)
I don’t know whether Health Care is a basic human right – but I do believe that America is rich enough and has the means to support their people in a humane fashion – and I can’t believe that we can’t find a way that works better than what we have now!