Money Moments on Oprah’s Big Give: Episode 4 – Miami
Sorry for the delay in getting this posted, I’ve been drowning in taxes, thank goodness for my DVR.
I have to say, now that we are 4 episodes into this show, I’m pretty disappointed. The judges seem to be mere celebrities, or maybe just Oprah’s friends. I would rather have known philanthropists or financial experts on the show. I also think that we don’t see enough of a teaching philosophy that could really be used to help people. I give an award each episode of what moment best highlights the old adage “you can give a man a fish, he eats for a day; teach him to fish and he eats for life”. Unfortunately this award is sometimes very hard to give.
Anyway, enough about my rant. This episode was filled with money moments, just not too many financial moments. This week, the teams headed to Miami.
Show spoilers to follow….
Upon arriving in Miami, the teams meet billionaire brothers Joe and Gavin Maloof.
The brothers give each person $100,000. The contestants had 24-hours to give the money in the most dramatic ways possible. But there are rules:
1. Everyone must work as an individual – no teams.
2. No one person can be the benefactor of more than $500.
3. No more than $10,000 can be spent at any one location.
4. Cash can not be directly given to any recipient.
Sounds easy, huh? Well, in reality it must be very difficult as only one person succeeded, and that was Steve. This show also had a twist that two people were going to be eliminated.
As I mentioned, Steve did the best job of getting rid of his money. He spent $30,000 at 4 different stores and then drove around an impoverished neighborhood handing out the goods.
Cameron, who converted his cash to traveler’s checks, did a few other things that were fun and impressive. One thing he did was to go to an auto body shop and pay the outstanding bills of random people’s repair work. Another creative thing he did was to negotiate the price of a boat down to $10,000 to give to an organization devoted to kids with disabilities.
Kim paid for a bunch of people’s gas at a local gas station. She also donated a bunch of pet supplies to a pet shelter. Kim had a hard time finding her way around the area. She spent too much time in her car and too little time giving away her money.
Brandi seemed to have a lot of fun with this challenge. The most dramatic thing that she did was to buy all of the flowers from a street side vendor. She then handed free flowers to all the cars passing by. She had a lot of fun, put a smile on many people’s faces, and in all honesty truly helped the people selling the flowers
Sheg’s most memorable moment was at a grocery store in an impoverished neighborhood. He paid the groceries for the first 100 people. The big winners here were the families that had all this food, and the store owners who made their margins.
Rachael impressed me in the early episodes, but seems to be struggling now. The most memorable thing that she did was to have a $500 shopping spree for 20 people at a local Target. (I’m beginning to think that Target is an official sponsor, maybe the teams are supposed to use Target wherever possible)
The eliminated players this week were Eric and Kim. Kim had a very hard time getting rid of her money. Eric gave an empty promise, which was a terrible mistake. He had promised the family of a dead police officer to help pay the funeral costs. This policeman was the first African American police officer in the Miami police department. What could have helped make him win made him lose when he couldn’t deliver.
The best moment of “teaching a man to fish” was probably when Brandi gave transit passes to, Charlee, a place that helps abused children find safe housing. Transit costs will allow some of these young mothers to travel to their jobs.
What would you have done? I, for one, would have pulled an all-nighter.
I’m watching and enjoying the show. I also have wondered if Target is an official sponsor as it seems like there are a lot of shopping sprees there. I also wondered if the contestants were given hours that they should not be on the streets in impoverished neighborhoods. No one mentioned doing any work at night and in fact many of them mentioned “starting in the morning.” There was one contestant (I can’t remember who) who allowed the headmistress of a school to have a shopping spree for the school. I would imagine I would have done something like that for 10 organizations: schools or non-profits. But I also understand that it took up time.
Also, I think that the officer was a fire fighter rather than police officer but I could have that wrong.
That makes sense about the hours, there is a camera crew that would have to be in place as well.
I think part of the reason we didn’t see shopping sprees for 10 groups is that they are judged on creativity.
I think they over thought much of this task because they wanted to be creative and dramatic.
The episode was fun. Wouldn’t it be nice to get money that you had to give away?
Phil,
Re. the question you raise about the expertise of the judges…I feel no one “owns” philanthropy, and I would probably have issues with any number of people who could have been picked as judges…so the fact that at least the 3 judges are philanthropists is enough for me. Although I reserve the right to change my mind. LOL My own issue with the judging is that there is no real thoughtful discourse about what constitutes a “successful” give.
Looking forward to tonight’s episode!
ALG –
True. Anyone can be a philanthropist…and hopefully this show motivates more people to “pay it forward” and to be givers.
I wish there was more discussion about “success” as well.
I think the problem is, many people will watch the show and think, “Why can’t this happen to me?” “Why can’t someone take me out of my miserable situation?”
The show has done very little along the way of helping the viewer with their situations.
I certainly have no disagreement with you on both those counts!
I think this was something great that could have been done. I just wiosh I could have been on the receiving end, since I am dsabled and have so many financial needs. Keep it going Oprah!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!