Under Earning Women and the Imposter Syndrome
‘œAs far as I’m concerned, being any gender is a drag.’ ‘“ Patti Smith
Much has been written about gender and money with women earning only a fraction of what men do. That said, sometimes the wage gap is reversed for gays.
All this talk got me thinking about what’s really holding women back when it comes to earnings. Is gender the real cause of disparity or at this stage, do we only have ourselves to blame? After all, I was brought up knowing that I could have any job that I wanted.
I can thank my parents for instilling this value. Is it safe to assume that most twenty and thirtysomething women were raised the same way?
Apparently not. In my money travels, I’ve learned that many women don’t feel this way. I recently interviewed Barbara Stanny, the author of Overcoming Underearning and daughter of the ‘œR’ in H&R Block said:
If you look at the 10 traits of an underearner ‘“ for example, they talk as if they’re trapped; they give away their power; they are self-saboteurs, codependent, vague about money and often anti-wealth ‘“ you can see every single trait is a result of a choice we made.
Above all, women must be willing to be uncomfortable, to do what they’re scared to do. The number one requirement to go to the next level in your life is the willingness to do what you think you can’t do. And a big part of that is valuing yourself.
Another way to characterize this is a phenomenon known as The Imposter Syndrome:
Individuals experiencing this syndrome seem unable to internalize their accomplishments. Regardless of what level of success they may have achieved in their chosen field of work or study, or what external proof they may have of their competence, they remain convinced internally that they do not deserve the success they have achieved and are really frauds.
Proofs of success are dismissed as luck, timing, or otherwise having deceived others into thinking they were more intelligent and competent than they believe themselves to be. This syndrome is thought to be particularly common among women who are successful in their given careers and is typically associated with academics.
Does any of this sound familiar? Take the Impostor Syndrome Quiz by Dr. Valerie Young and then continue on to her Ten Tips to Overcoming the Imposter Syndrome.
Money has a lot to do with self-limiting obstacles to success. Women tend to negotiate differently than men when it comes to salaries and asking for more money. Why are we willing to leave money on the table? If self-employed, why is it so hard to charge what we’re worth?
I don’t have answers. Rather the point with this post is to raise the question and hear from you. Your comments are welcomed below!
Yes, I feel like an imposter quite a lot. I go through phases of feeling like I am going to get fired, or that work will realise that I’m not who they thought they’d hired.
I was brought up to think that I could do any job, but I didn’t know any women (and still don’t know many) who really did anything other than (compared to their husbands) a less important part-time job.
I never think that role models matter to me that much, but maybe I’m mistaken.
Let me count the ways in which I love your articles. 😀
This actually got forwarded over to my father’s new wife who is an interior designer/general contractor. We were just talking how sometimes people are amazed at the prices she charges (over a hundred and twenty an hour). In reality, she says it’s the the norm for the industry. I admire that she’s strong enough not to feel as though she should charge less, nor does she waiver on her prices.
I feel like an imposter all the time–even in my own fields. I see all the flaws in my work, all the places where I need to grow and think of them as flaws, not opportunities to grow or places where I’m just not perfect yet. *sigh*
I’ll look into that article and see if there’s any hope. 😉
P.S. I’m getting better at charging what I’m worth! 🙂
I see myself doing this and even though I feel completely capable at what I do! Be strong charge alot!
Plonkee: Interesting to hear that it’s not only the ladies feeling this way. Thanks for sharing.
Vixen: Thanks for the anecdote. Sounds like your step-mom is a good role model.
Mrs. Micah: There is hope. Negative self-talk is one of those recordings playing constantly in our heads. I try to consciously change what’s recorded. Sure, sometimes it feels like mind games, but mind games work. “We are what we think. All that we are arises with our thoughts. With our thoughts, we make the world.â€
Nicole: Charging what we’re worth is so important for women… whether it’s our day rates or starting salary. Paula listed some good books on this topic in her post about How to Ask for More Money!
In this week’s Carnival of the Insanities.