Using Good Debt to Pay for a House, Car, or Education
Hello again! Cate here, talking, as usual, about debt.
The point of my series here at Queercents is to talk about the dangers of getting into debt. But when I strenuously suggest avoiding debt, I’m not talking about all debt. Good Debt and Bad Debt are polar opposites and mortal enemies.
Bad Debt can make you miserable and have wide-reaching negative consequences in your life. Good Debt can enable you to buy a house, or go to school, or own a car. And if it’s properly managed, Good Debt is a healthy part of your financial life.
Good Debt generally results from your conscious decision to borrow money for a big ticket item that will produce concrete benefits to your life. The bad kind of credit card debt that I’ve talked about often result from the opposite–an unconscious trickle of spending on small items that produces no obvious benefit. I’ve had both kinds:
Bad Debt: $5,000 credit card debt from living beyond my means, accumulated slowly over time due to my lack of consciousness and foresight about money.
Good Debt: $10,000 car loan at a low interest rate, cautiously decided upon, to enable me to get around.
If you find the idea of Big Loans daunting … good! It means you’re paying attention–owing that much money is a scary thought. I was in a near-panic when I signed a piece of paper agreeing to pay someone back $10,000 for a car! People who get into Big Loans thoughtlessly are not getting into good debt.
Just because it’s scary, doesn’t mean we shouldn’t do it, however. There’s a ton of good resources to help you decide when and how to get into good debt. (Check out Queercents on student loans and mortgages!) To get you started, here are three basic planning guidelines to think about:
- Shop Around. This seems like a bit of a no-brainer. Look before you leap is always a good rule to follow in personal finance. In the case of taking on a Big Loan, it behooves you to look at all available sources of financing. With car loans, for example don’t just depend on the car dealership, ask around at banks. I got my auto loan from Capitol One and walked into the dealership with a loan ready to go–it saved me hundreds of dollars in interest charges.
- Take a Hard Look at Your Financial Situation. Think carefully about how you are going to be able to afford the loan payments. Look at your budget or spending plan and figure out where those dollars are going to come from. What are you going to have to give up? Don’t forget to account for associated costs. When buying a car/education/house, you’ll have to pay for gasoline/books/home repair, etc. as well, and this can end up being a good chunk of the cost. Factor the total cost of ownership into your financial assessment.
- Have a Concrete Re-Payment Plan. Please, please, please never accept a loan without a concrete idea of how you’re going to pay it back. Credit cards actively discourage this kind of thinking, which is one of my biggest problems with them. Never tell yourself “oh, I’ll pay it off someday” or “I’m sure to get a raise eventually.” Down that road lies bad, very bad debt.
Before you accept a loan, make an outline of how it’s going to get paid back. Write down your payments and any early payments you’re planning. Even if this plan changes over time, just having it set down in a plan will help you make wiser financial choices over time.
My own experience with Good Debt was instructive. I always made my car loan payment on time, but when I decided to sell my car while still paying it off, I discovered I had negative equity–I owed more than the car was worth. I also discovered how hard the bank made it to make extra payments to the principle. The bank is in the business of prolonging your loan, not helping you pay it back early!
Have you had a good or bad experience with a Big Loan? I’d love to hear about it in the comments.
Photo credit: stock.xchng.
Well said my friend. In fact I just paid off my car loan of about $10k. I paid it off in 12 months, I’m very proud of me.
I’ve never had student loans, college was covered for me. Grad school isn’t out of the picture though, so I’m starting to read up on a loans a lot now.
Cate: You were smart to shop around for an auto loan before walking into the dealership. ConsumerReports had a good overview of car loan options and just as you said, encouraged people to shy away from financing arranged at the dealership:
Great advice, Cate. The only big debt I’ve carried has been student loans. I got those paid off this year by doing exactly what you said – having a payment plan. And when tax refunds rolled around, that went on the student loan. This year the tax refund is going in my IRA, but that’s another post.
Congrats on the car loan, weakonomist! (Love the name, btw.) That takes a lot of discipline. And I know what you mean about student loans. I was lucky enough to avoid them, too, and now I’m daunted by the thought of grad school debt.
Congrats on paying down your student debt, Serena! Putting your refund towards debt (or retirement) is a good practice. I don’t think I’m quite there, yet–I always wind up spending mine on something fun and frivolous. =)
I would argue that car loan debt is not ‘good’ debt. Buying real estate has traditionally been a good investment, though, arguably, this is not the case currently, since many people have mortgages that exceed the value of their homes. However, as long as a down payment is 25% or more, real estate is still a pretty solid investment. Education, too, is generally a valuable asset – it can open up new and profitable career paths.
A car loses value the minute you drive it off the lots – or so I’ve read. Buying a car with cash is the only way to go, they say. I tend to agree. Then again, I’m biased. I am fortunate enough to live in a big city (Vancouver, BC), and live in the downtown core, a 7-minute walk from work. The Cooperative Auto Network supplies all my driving needs, from client visits to Ikea or Home Depot trips. I only use a car when I need it, pay only for the distance I drive and time I am using the car, and never pay for parking or insurance.
If I didn’t live in a big city, or needed my car for commuting, I realise the situation would be entirely different. But I still believe that saving up funds for a significant purchase (like we’ve been saving up for kitchen renos) is the best way to go.
But I’ve been wrong before…